Jump to content

Bcs Craziness

emmitt01

By emmitt01
in Mean Green Football

 Share

Recommended Posts

emmitt01 Grand Master

emmitt01

Posted
Posted

So the BCS standings came out today. They are as follows:

1)Bama

2)Texas Tech

3)TU

4)Florida

5)OU

6)USC

7)Utah

Now let's look at how things could get hinky. We'll assume that USC wins out like they should.

Tech and OU have this next week off. Bama plays Miss State. UT plays Kansas. Let's assume they both win. Florida plays South Carolina and we can assume they'll win. Everything stays the same at the top.

The week of 11/22 Tech plays OU. Let's assume for arguments sake that OU wins. That same week UT plays aTm on Thanksgiving night. Let's assume they win. Bama is off. Florida gets the Citadel and should roll. So, that week could easily end with Bama #1, UT #2, OU #3 Florida #4 and Tech falling to #5...or maybe #6 if USC moves up.

Ok, the week of 11/29 rolls around. UT is done with their season and sitting at #2 having played aTm on that Thursday. Bama plays Auburn in their rivalry game. Auburn hasn't looked near good enough to beat Bama so let's give Bama the edge. Tech plays Baylor and we'll give them the win...but a win at Baylor isn't all that impressive. Florida should beat Florida State. OU plays OkState. What if OU loses this game?(It's conceivable) Well you conceivably end this week with Bama still #1, UT #2, Florida at #3, USC #4, Tech #5, and OU #6.

Ok so the Big XII season is over with UT at #2, Tech at #5 and OU at #6. OU has two conference losses. UT and Tech each have one. So, OU is out of the Big XII south champion discussion. UT is ranked higher in the BCS than Tech but doesn't go to the Big XII title game by virtue of the head to head tie-breaker. Uh oh. So your Big XII south champion is potentially ranked lower than the team they beat during the regular season.

Now the real madness. Bama plays Florida on 12/6 for the SEC title. The winner of this game would end the regular season in either the #1 or #2 spot and would be lined up to play UT in the national title game. (Bama wins they stay at #1 and Florida falls to #6 or so...Florida wins and they move up to #2 probably and Bama goes to 4,5, or 6)

You may be thinking, "Emmitt, it's no big deal because if Tech wins the Big XII title game they vault into the national title game." But do they? Would Mack Brown whine to the media to "take control of college football" again...and would it work? Would a 1 loss USC team move into the title game since they lost early and would be looking pretty impressive to end the season? What about Bama? Their only loss is in the SEC title game...should they get another shot?

Bottom line is that this thing could play out so many goofy ways (a few of which could call for a Tech/UT rematch or a Florida/Bama rematch). And if voters voted in a manner which ensures that you don't have an all SEC or all Big XII national title game then they'd have to ignore actual strength of schedule or quality losses/wins.

BeanCounterGrad'03 Rookie

BeanCounterGrad'03

Posted
Posted

Nothing personal against you wanting to start some BCS talk, but I'm not wasting much time worrying about these senarios until there is a decent (i.e. 8+ team) playoff system implemented.

That being said...I'm rooting for the underdog Tech to go all the way.

CMJ Grand Master

CMJ

Posted
Posted

We'll see what happens. I expect it to be the SEC champ vs the Big XII champ no matter the outcome.

Granted I think USC is the best team right now, but they have no argument really with their loss to Oregon State in a down year for the Pac-10.

GoMeanGreen1999 Rising Star

GoMeanGreen1999

Posted
Posted

And you could have all three of UT, TT and OU finishing in the top 8 of the BCS, but because of the stupid BCS rules only two of them could go to a BCS game with one of them being left out, meanwhile no team in the Big East is ranked, yet they have an automatic bid into the BCS.

The musers brought this up this morning: Top ranked defense in the Big 12 this season: OU, ranked #51.

CMJ Grand Master

CMJ

Posted
Posted

The musers brought this up this morning: Top ranked defense in the Big 12 this season: OU, ranked #51.

Which is why I think USC is the best team right now. The reputation of the Pac-10 is all offense, no defense...wide open, blah, blah.

USC hads given up 60 points for the season. So, less than a touchdown per game in the supposedly all offense Pac-10.

THOR Proficient

THOR

Posted
Posted

Well, twice teams have failed to win the Big 12 yet still played in the national championship game.

From Wikipedia (I know, I know): In 2001 Nebraska played Miami (Florida), after losing to Colorado during the regular season and, therefore, did not play in the Big 12 Conference Championship game. In 2003 Oklahoma played LSU despite losing to Kansas State 35-7 in the Big 12 Conference title game.

didn't they change the rule a while back about having to win your conference championship in order to go to the bcs title game?

Quoner Veteran

Quoner

Posted
Posted

Good Analysis Emmitt... I was thinking about alot of the scenarios you played out.... I do think that Tech will fall to OU in Norman....

Also I think USC is alot better than what people give them credit for.

I decided out of shame, I will not pick against Tech anymore this year. I also am proud to still call Red Raider Gum my best friend.

CMJ Grand Master

CMJ

Posted
Posted

They didn't make a rule...but I think it's sort of expected now that the voters will vault a conference champion over a school that isn't.

Like LSU moved over Georgia last season in the Final Poll.

UNTFan23 Rising Star

UNTFan23

Posted
Posted

Which is why I think USC is the best team right now. The reputation of the Pac-10 is all offense, no defense...wide open, blah, blah.

USC hads given up 60 points for the season. So, less than a touchdown per game in the supposedly all offense Pac-10.

See, I can't call USC the best team out there cause they lost to an un-ranked Oregon State team. What hurts USC even more is that Utah beat OSU a couple weeks later. I almost expect Utah to jump past USC since Utah has yet to play BYU.

CMJ Grand Master

CMJ

Posted
Posted

See, I can't call USC the best team out there cause they lost to an un-ranked Oregon State team. What hurts USC even more is that Utah beat OSU a couple weeks later. I almost expect Utah to jump past USC since Utah has yet to play BYU.

Of course OSU lost on the road to Utah.

And OSU is ranked in acouple of the polls now, though not in the BCS as of yet.

I wouldn't RANK USC as #1...I just think they're probably the best team RIGHT NOW. Texas Tech or Alabama definitely deserve their rankings though because they haven't slipped up.

NT80 Grand Master

NT80

Posted
Posted

My hope is that the BCS is a mess and there are many unhappy fans, coaches, and ADs.

Enough madness to scrap this human-manipulated computer poll and take it to the field for a true playoff, 32 teams of course! :D

untbowler Grand Master

untbowler

Posted
Posted

Well funny to hear the hypocrite Bob Stoops railing on the BCS when it saved his ass when he choked in the Big 12 Championship as well as helped Nebraska in 2000 or so. For any coach in the Big 12 to complain about inequities in the BCS is just plain funny and hypocritical.

LongJim Experienced

LongJim

Posted
Posted

You may be thinking, "Emmitt, it's no big deal because if Tech wins the Big XII title game they vault into the national title game." But do they?

Yes. If they win out, they will play for the MNC. If they don't, then their 2 games against 1AA schools will hurt them in the computers and in the human polls--as they should.

Would a 1 loss USC team move into the title game since they lost early and would be looking pretty impressive to end the season?

No, because their strength of schedule is not high enough, and they got owned by an unranked team at home. Voters aren't going to forget it. The two teams to watch (IMO) are Tech and Florida. Harris and USA Today have Florida #3. Computers don't like them as much, but if they knock off Bama, all bets are off. Texas needs help, and USC needs a LOT of help.

THOR Proficient

THOR

Posted
Posted

Yes. If they win out, they will play for the MNC. If they don't, then their 2 games against 1AA schools will hurt them in the computers and in the human polls--as they should.

No, because their strength of schedule is not high enough, and they got owned by an unranked team at home. Voters aren't going to forget it. The two teams to watch (IMO) are Tech and Florida. Harris and USA Today have Florida #3. Computers don't like them as much, but if they knock off Bama, all bets are off. Texas needs help, and USC needs a LOT of help.

sc lost at oregon state, not at home

TIgreen01 Veteran

TIgreen01

Posted
Posted

I used to favor a playoff scenario, but have absolutely no faith that we'd ever be given access. Therefore, I hope this plays out in a fairly civilized manner. I think a +1 game would be the best option out there right now b/c I truly don't believe you'd ever see a playoff with more than 8 teams invited--which would ultimately just seed teams under a similar formula to what the current BCS uses.

Now...if by some miracle, a playoff that allowed each conference champion access were to come about.....I'd definitely like to see it.

emmitt01 Grand Master

emmitt01

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Yes. If they win out, they will play for the MNC. If they don't, then their 2 games against 1AA schools will hurt them in the computers and in the human polls--as they should.

No, I was asking if Tech, should they lose to OU yet still go to the Big XII title game by virtue of tie-breakers, would still make it to the national championship. I'm not so sure they would.

bflan Newbie

bflan

Posted
Posted

This is a "mythical" National Championship since there are NO playoffs. It still boggles my mind what a true 16 team (or more) playoff system could do for college football. It would make March Madness look silly.

LongJim Experienced

LongJim

Posted
Posted (edited)

No, I was asking if Tech, should they lose to OU yet still go to the Big XII title game by virtue of tie-breakers, would still make it to the national championship. I'm not so sure they would.

Ah, okay. I misunderstood. I'm not positive they'd go to the B12 with a loss to OU. Three way tie then, if everyone wins out. Not sure how they'd break that tie. My personal opinion is that there is no way they will make the MNC without being undefeated. BCS bowl, yes.

Edited by LongJim

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Tell a friend

    Love GoMeanGreen.com? Tell a friend!

  • What's going on Mean Green?

    1. 8

      UAB (12/31/24)

      I'll be there. How is everyone feeling as we enter conference play? Overall I'm feeling good. We are 2nd in NET in the conference. The two best publicly available models, KenPom and Bart Torvik, have us as the 2nd best team in conference and finishing that way. Our defense has been really good; it's actually better than last season. The biggest improvement is in the defensive rebounding. We are pulling down 74.8% of defensive boards compared to 68% last year. Of course the team isn't without concerns. Although we start the same lineup every game, we haven't found a consistent closing one. There isn't a 'go to' scorer. The shot creation and/or shooting has been lacking in long stretches. So far our adjusted offensive efficiency is the lowest it's been since the 2019 season, but I don't think (hope) it will necessarily stay that way. I'd be disappointed if we don't finish at least top 4 in conference. The conference, as others have noted in many threads, just isn't as good as last season. Last season there were 4 other teams in the top 100 of KenPom and 7 in the top 150. This season there are 2 other teams in the top 100 and 5 in the top 150. Last year in conference we played 3 Q1 games and 5 Q2 games; this year we're projected to play 1 Q1 game and 3 Q2 games. A top 4 finish in conference means that we would need to win 3 games in Ft. Worth to go to the big dance. That's always the dream. The NIT as the consolation prize wouldn't be bad either. Could we host a NIT game again? Last year Indiana St., Princeton, and Bradley hosted opening round games. That would be a fun atmosphere.
      • 1
      • Upvote
      Son Of A Flying Worm in Mean Green Basketball
    2. 25

      SMU's Last Bowl Win...

      Whoa, and yet another thread about the SMU Mustangs.
      dodgefan in Mean Green Football
    3. 25

      SMU's Last Bowl Win...

      Zoom the photo, it's the Houston Christian opener.
      dodgefan in Mean Green Football
    4. 7

      State of College Football

      You have to consider many of these are the only entertainment option in town. Fargo, ND vs Denton. The entire state of ND follows the Bison.
      UNTLifer in Mean Green Football
    5. 24

      Is it just me or is Eric Morris destined for great things?

      It's just you bro. Same reason why you supported McCarney's #Hit6 campaign. The bar is in Hell.
      Cougar King in Mean Green Football

  • Popular Contributors

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
      15,506
    • Most Online
      1,865
    Jepper
    Newest Member
    Jepper
    Joined

  • Most Points

    1. 1
      El Paso Eagle
      El Paso Eagle
      170,499
    2. 2
      NT80
      NT80
      138,223
    3. 3
      KingDL1
      KingDL1
      131,790
    4. 4
      greenminer
      greenminer
      124,260
    5. 5
      TheReal_jayD
      TheReal_jayD
      109,359

  • Biggest Gamblers

    1. 1
      EdtheEagle
      EdtheEagle
      26,591,647
    2. 2
      UNTLifer
      UNTLifer
      4,480,984
    3. 3
      untphd
      untphd
      842,545
    4. 4
      flyonthewall
      flyonthewall
      670,422
    5. 5
      3_n_out
      3_n_out
      578,480
    6. 6
      SteaminWillieBeamin
    7. 7
      UNT_FH_FR_YR
      UNT_FH_FR_YR
      454,039
    8. 8
      cousin oliver
      cousin oliver
      448,120
    9. 9
      meangreenfaninno
    10. 10
      South Texas Green

WE BELIEVE IN THE MEAN GREEN!

News

Recruiting

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue. Please review our full Privacy Policy before using our site.