Chandler H O F?

[Wag Tag]

Can you go into the HOF if you only played a year for UNT? I could see this coming up a lot especially in BB.

[untcampbell]

A bowl win would qualify, if you are among the crowd who believe only the truly elite (exceptional, unusually successful) should be selected to a Hall of Fame. That said, I hope he gets in because he led NT to two bowl game wins.

 

GMG

Edited October 30 by untcampbell
clarification

[MeanGreen_MBA]

22 minutes ago, Wag Tag said:

Can you go into the HOF if you only played a year for UNT? I could see this coming up a lot especially in BB.

I wouldn’t vote for it. HoF is more than 1 season of success. 

[97and03]

[MeanGreenTexan]

[Green with Envy]

if he plays 2 seasons and we accomplish something (AAC champ game or bowl victory), then I'm in favor.   if not, then i'm not.    i need something more than 'threw for a s-ton of yards' to get my vote.  

[MeanGreen22]

If he plays 2 healthy years, he'll be in the top 3 in passing yards and top 5 in passing TDs. Throw in a bowl win and he might get a statue lol

Edited October 30 by MeanGreen22

[Big Z]

6 minutes ago, MeanGreen22 said:

If he plays 2 healthy years, he'll be in the top 3 in passing yards and top 5 in passing TDs. Throw in a bowl win and he might get a statue lol

All you got to do is win a bowl game lol....geez

[RBP79]

I'd  say two years. Guess we'll  see if he sticks around for year two. Don't  see his favorite target sticking around though..

[Mean Green 93-98]

[greenminer]

4 hours ago, MeanGreen_MBA said:

I wouldn’t vote for it. HoF is more than 1 season of success. 

It is not.  Evidence A: DT.

It should be more than one season of success, though.

If Morris finishes out this season with a bowl win and leads the country with these stats, they will put him in.

Edited October 30 by greenminer

[Mean Green 93-98]

4 minutes ago, greenminer said:

It is not.  Evidence A: DT.

Not great evidence.  While only one of his seasons was significantly successful, he also had a full career as a North Texas QB, 3 years as starter.

If Chandler only plays here one year, that would mean he left after this season to play somewhere else.  DT's HOF case was helped by the fact that he continued to support NT (or at least appeared to) after his playing career was over.

Not to mention, DT was far from a slam-dunk HOF-er.

[SilverEagle]

We have at least three examples of players with two years of experience getting into the HOF. None of them were involved in a Bowl.

John Love

Vidal Carlin

Barry Moore

 

Anyone is welcome peruse the list if they want.

North Texas Athletics Hall of Fame - University of North Texas Athletics

[Cougar King]

Throwing for 2800 yards is all it takes to get hall of fame consideration at UNT. 

 

The bar really is in hell.

[UNTLifer]

5 hours ago, MeanGreen_MBA said:

I wouldn’t vote for it. HoF is more than 1 season of success. 

Would you vote for Jamario?

[greenminer]

2 hours ago, Mean Green 93-98 said:

Not great evidence.  While only one of his seasons was significantly successful, he also had a full career as a North Texas QB, 3 years as starter.

He got in because of his senior year.  Period.  And I believe he gets in without needing the other years.

[Mean Green 93-98]

42 minutes ago, greenminer said:

He got in because of his senior year.  Period.  And I believe he gets in without needing the other years.

You think if he would have transferred in one year, played the kind of year he had in 2013, then transferred out, that he still makes the HOF?  I guess we'll have to agree to strongly disagree on this one.

[MeanGreenZen]

2 hours ago, UNTLifer said:

Would you vote for Jamario?

I would. Jamario had one magical season and other productive seasons. 
Chandler Rogers was here for one year. Did pretty good then left and the guy who replaced him is WAY better. That is not HOF stuff.

[Coffee and TV]

He might be the best QB we've ever had, but pump the brakes, it's been 8 games. 

[Big Z]

33 minutes ago, Coffee and TV said:

He might be the best QB we've ever had, but pump the brakes, it's been 8 games. 

Agree, we still have 4 games left

[Cooley]

Hell no

[NT93]

3 hours ago, UNTLifer said:

Would you vote for Jamario?

This is the first thought I had.  I’d always said “no,” but a poster on here made me look at it differently.  If Jamario’s career had gone in reverse and his freshman season was his senior season, he’s a no-brainer.  But, that wasn’t the case, so it’s debatable.  

As for Chandler, I say no to anyone who only played one year, no matter how great the season.

 

[Big Z]

8 hours ago, UNTLifer said:

Would you vote for Jamario?

 

[Coffee and TV]

18 hours ago, Big Z said:

 

remember when we used that logo but instead of an eagle head it just had "North Texas" in the middle? I remember wondering why people were so mad about son of worm when that was what existed before. 

Edited Thursday at 09:06 PM by Coffee and TV

[UNTLifer]

And the side story, Cobbs, being unselfish, coached Jamario up while injured and he's right back on the sideline still doing that.