Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

That light could have come on twelve weeks ago if Mac had not played family-friends favoritism that absolutely blinded him, and plugged DaMarcus in.

I'm not sure anyone can refute that Mac stuck with the wrong DB-playing-QB, when he should have focused upon developing Mr. Smith.

  • Upvote 1
  • Downvote 1
Posted

I'm actually excited to watch every game the rest of the season...our defense will probably keep us from winning games but I'm anxious to see how D Smith does...next season...possibly a firm, quality starting quarterback and a fresh start at HC.  I can get behind that. 

  • Upvote 3
Posted (edited)

1st NT QB to throw for 200 & run for 100? Wow, I'm surprised it's never happened here.  That's a nice stat to have to your name. I'm expecting that to go to 300 & 100 during his time here. 

Edited by Got5onIt
  • Upvote 2
Posted (edited)

I'm not sure anyone can refute that Mac stuck with the wrong DB-playing-QB, when he should have focused upon developing Mr. Smith.

Both Smith and Canales said they had a come to Jesus meeting where it was explained to Smith he needed to do more, to actually do the little things needed to get the starting job. Both acknowledged that Smith started doing those things only two weeks ago. And both implied Smith had already been told he needed to do these things to start and he had not. It wasn't until the most recent conversation that Smith finally understood what he had been told and finally started to act on it. When Smith did the right things, he was given more of a chance. So the people refuting you idea are Smith and Canales in the DRC. 

We can only imagine what the season would have been like if Smith had started doing what he was asked during Fall camp instead of just two weeks ago.

Edited by VideoEagle
  • Upvote 2
Posted

Both Smith and Canales said they had a come to Jesus meeting where it was explained to Smith he needed to do more, to actually do the little things needed to get the starting job. Both acknowledged that Smith started doing those things only two weeks ago. And both implied Smith had already been told he needed to do these things to start and he had not. It wasn't until the most recent conversation that Smith finally understood what he had been told and finally started to act on it. When Smith did the right things, he was given more of a chance. So the people refuting you idea are Smith and Canales in the DRC. 

We can only imagine what the season would have been like if Smith had started doing what he was asked during Fall camp instead of just two weeks ago.

Or he was biding his time and trying to be a good player and teammate and couldn't wait any longer after sitting so far behind Mini. 

I'd bet there's some truth to that story, but doubt it's the whole story of why he wasn't playing. Smith and Chico are still being kind to Mac.

  • Upvote 3
  • Downvote 1
Posted

Both Smith and Canales said they had a come to Jesus meeting where it was explained to Smith he needed to do more, to actually do the little things needed to get the starting job. Both acknowledged that Smith started doing those things only two weeks ago. And both implied Smith had already been told he needed to do these things to start and he had not. It wasn't until the most recent conversation that Smith finally understood what he had been told and finally started to act on it. When Smith did the right things, he was given more of a chance. So the people refuting you idea are Smith and Canales in the DRC. 

We can only imagine what the season would have been like if Smith had started doing what he was asked during Fall camp instead of just two weeks ago.

Agreed 100%.  But it is worth observing that, during his radio, Coach Chico was saying how Marshall had never seen a QB like DaMarcus, and how he would give them problems.  Can you imagine his saying something like that about Andrew?

  • Upvote 1
Posted

Agreed 100%.  But it is worth observing that, during his radio, Coach Chico was saying how Marshall had never seen a QB like DaMarcus, and how he would give them problems.  Can you imagine his saying something like that about Andrew?

Yes, but only the first part

  • Upvote 6
Posted

What I don't understand is why this "come to Jesus" meeting took so long to happen. Why didn't Canales approach him, earlier, and say, "hey, you want to play, this is what you have to do, meet me in the film room after practice." Are we to believe this was the case, and DSMith said no and just didn't do it? Seems like the egos of the coaching staff are detrimental to developing this roster. Not all these kids are going to go above and beyond on their own. 

  • Upvote 4
  • Downvote 1
Posted

What I don't understand is why this "come to Jesus" meeting took so long to happen. Why didn't Canales approach him, earlier, and say, "hey, you want to play, this is what you have to do, meet me in the film room after practice." Are we to believe this was the case, and DSMith said no and just didn't do it? Seems like the egos of the coaching staff are detrimental to developing this roster. Not all these kids are going to go above and beyond on their own. 

this

Posted

According to this article, it kinda sounds like Damarcus had another hurdle to clear in Chico himself.    As much as you and many others would like to blame McCarney's nepotism as 100% of the reason why Damarcus didn't start from day 1, I don't believe that to be true.

Both Smith and Canales said they had a come to Jesus meeting where it was explained to Smith he needed to do more, to actually do the little things needed to get the starting job. Both acknowledged that Smith started doing those things only two weeks ago. And both implied Smith had already been told he needed to do these things to start and he had not. It wasn't until the most recent conversation that Smith finally understood what he had been told and finally started to act on it. When Smith did the right things, he was given more of a chance. So the people refuting you idea are Smith and Canales in the DRC. 

We can only imagine what the season would have been like if Smith had started doing what he was asked during Fall camp instead of just two weeks ago.

It's called narrative with a side of spin, and its something our AD excels at and Vito is nearly fully complicit in. Notice when the same lines about McNulty and Derek Thompson would endlessly be repeated by Vito? All the way up until a coaching and QB change is established? It's a continued through-line of narrative.

The folks I know who work in the AD have confirmed this to be true.

  • Upvote 1
Posted

“I lost my cool, which is really uncharacteristic of coach Canales,” Canales said. 

The 3rd person speak from Chico never gets old.  It's one of the reasons that I actually read/watch his interviews.    

  • Upvote 1
Posted

It's called narrative with a side of spin, and its something our AD excels at and Vito is nearly fully complicit in. Notice when the same lines about McNulty and Derek Thompson would endlessly be repeated by Vito? All the way up until a coaching and QB change is established? It's a continued through-line of narrative.

The folks I know who work in the AD have confirmed this to be true.

The AD was not the interviewee in this article.  Brett was publicly calling for Damarcus to get a shot several weeks ago.  Why would he "comply" to the AD's "spin" when he's been mucking it up already?

I'm certainly not saying there was no nepotism at all...  it was pretty obvious.   But regardless of who you are, if you miss Spring practice and all of the coaching that comes with it, you're behind the 8ball with an old-school dude like McCarney.  You're also behind the 8ball when trying to take Chico's paper tests that he values so much.

  • Upvote 1
Posted

But regardless of who you are, if you miss Spring practice and all of the coaching that comes with it, you're behind the 8ball with an old-school dude like McCarney. 

This, fellas. Tryna tell y'all October would be the soonest DaMarcus would start.

  • Upvote 1
Posted

It's called narrative with a side of spin, and its something our AD excels at and Vito is nearly fully complicit in. Notice when the same lines about McNulty and Derek Thompson would endlessly be repeated by Vito? All the way up until a coaching and QB change is established? It's a continued through-line of narrative.

The folks I know who work in the AD have confirmed this to be true.

So it's a giant conspiracy on which not only Smith and Canales are participants, but Vito as well? Perhaps it is.

But I think it far more likely Smith and Canales told the truth to Vito and he simply reported what he was told. 

  • Upvote 2
Posted

It's awful hard for Chico to tell DS that the only reason he's not starting is because of Mac when Mac is no longer involved in the decision therefore the come to Jesus meeting was much more intense this time around and I would bet real money that it was more truthful this time also.

Posted

The AD was not the interviewee in this article.  Brett was publicly calling for Damarcus to get a shot several weeks ago.  Why would he "comply" to the AD's "spin" when he's been mucking it up already?

I'm certainly not saying there was no nepotism at all...  it was pretty obvious.   But regardless of who you are, if you miss Spring practice and all of the coaching that comes with it, you're behind the 8ball with an old-school dude like McCarney.  You're also behind the 8ball when trying to take Chico's paper tests that he values so much.

Sorry, AD can be both Director and Department, and I meant the broader of the two with this usage.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue. Please review our full Privacy Policy before using our site.